Advertisements

Exploring Investment Options for College Savings

Introduction

College education is one of the most important and valuable investments that you can make for yourself or your children. However, college education is also one of the most expensive and challenging investments that you can make, as the costs of tuition, fees, books, supplies, room and board, and other expenses, continue to rise every year, and often exceed the available financial aid, scholarships, grants, or loans.

According to the College Board, the average cost of attending a public four-year college in the United States, for the 2020-2021 academic year, was $22,180 for in-state students, and $38,640 for out-of-state students. The average cost of attending a private four-year college in the United States, for the same academic year, was $50,770. These costs do not include transportation, personal expenses, or health insurance, which can add thousands of dollars more to the total cost of attendance.

Therefore, it is essential to start saving for college as early and as much as possible, to reduce the financial burden and stress, and to increase the opportunities and choices, for yourself or your children, when it comes to pursuing higher education. However, saving for college is not as simple as putting money in a regular savings account, or a piggy bank. You need to consider various factors, such as the time horizon, the inflation rate, the tax implications, the risk and return trade-off, and the eligibility and availability, of different investment options, that can help you grow your money, and achieve your college savings goals.

In this article, we will explore some of the most common and popular investment options for college savings, such as 529 college savings plans, Coverdell education savings accounts, UGMA and UTMA accounts, Roth IRAs, and high-yield savings accounts. We will also discuss some of the benefits and features, limitations and drawbacks, and tips and strategies, of each investment option, and how to choose the best one for your situation and goals.

Importance of Saving for College

Saving for college is important for many reasons, such as:

  • Reducing the need for debt: Saving for college can help you reduce the need for borrowing money, such as student loans, to pay for college expenses. Borrowing money can be costly and risky, as you have to pay interest and fees, and repay the principal, over a long period of time, which can affect your cash flow, your credit score, and your financial future. Saving for college can help you avoid or minimize debt, and save money on interest and fees, and improve your financial health and stability.
  • Increasing the chances of admission and graduation: Saving for college can help you increase the chances of getting admitted and graduating from the college of your choice, or your children’s choice. Having a college savings fund can show the college admissions officers, that you are serious and committed, to pursuing higher education, and that you have the financial resources and support, to afford and complete your college degree. Saving for college can also help you avoid or reduce the need for working part-time or full-time, while attending college, which can interfere with your academic performance, your extracurricular activities, and your social life. Saving for college can help you focus on your studies and your goals, and improve your academic outcomes and achievements.
  • Enhancing the quality of life and career: Saving for college can help you enhance the quality of your life and career, by enabling you to pursue your passions and interests, and to develop your skills and knowledge, through higher education. Higher education can open up many doors and opportunities, for personal and professional growth and development, such as higher income, better employment, greater satisfaction, and more impact. Saving for college can help you realize your potential and aspirations, and make a positive difference in your life and the world.

Overview of Investment Options for College Savings

There are many investment options for college savings, that you can choose from, depending on your situation and goals. However, not all investment options are created equal, and they have different advantages and disadvantages, that you should consider, before making a decision. Here is a brief overview of some of the most common and popular investment options for college savings, and their main characteristics:

  • 529 college savings plans: These are tax-advantaged investment accounts, that are sponsored by states or educational institutions, and that are designed specifically for saving for college expenses. 529 plans allow you to invest your money in a variety of investment options, such as mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, or target-date funds, and to withdraw your money tax-free, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses, such as tuition, fees, books, supplies, room and board, and computers. 529 plans also offer high contribution limits, flexibility in changing beneficiaries, and protection from creditors.
  • Coverdell education savings accounts (ESAs): These are tax-advantaged investment accounts, that are similar to 529 plans, but with some differences. Coverdell ESAs allow you to invest your money in a wider range of investment options, such as stocks, bonds, or certificates of deposit, and to withdraw your money tax-free, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses, not only for college, but also for elementary and secondary education. However, Coverdell ESAs have lower contribution limits, stricter eligibility requirements, and earlier distribution deadlines, than 529 plans.
  • Uniform Gifts to Minors Act (UGMA) and Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) accounts: These are custodial accounts, that allow you to transfer money or other assets, such as stocks, bonds, or real estate, to a minor, under the name and control of a custodian, such as a parent or a guardian, until the minor reaches the age of majority, which is usually 18 or 21, depending on the state. UGMA and UTMA accounts are not specifically designed for saving for college, but they can be used for any purpose, including education. However, UGMA and UTMA accounts have some drawbacks, such as limited tax benefits, loss of control, and negative impact on financial aid eligibility, that you should be aware of.
  • Roth IRA for education savings: This is a type of individual retirement account, that allows you to invest your money in a variety of investment options, such as stocks, bonds, or mutual funds, and to withdraw your contributions and earnings tax-free, after age 59 and a half, or for certain exceptions, such as education. Roth IRA is not specifically designed for saving for college, but it can be used for that purpose, as you can withdraw your contributions, at any time, without penalty, and your earnings, before age 59 and a half, without penalty, but with taxes, as long as you use them for qualified education expenses. However, Roth IRA has some limitations, such as contribution limits, income limits, and opportunity costs, that you should consider.
  • High-yield savings accounts: These are bank accounts, that offer higher interest rates, than regular savings accounts, and that are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution. High-yield savings accounts are not specifically designed for saving for college, but they can be used for that purpose, as they offer safety, liquidity, and stability, for your money. However, high-yield savings accounts have some disadvantages, such as lower returns, inflation risk, and tax liability, that you should be aware of.

529 College Savings Plans

One of the most popular and beneficial investment options for college savings, is the 529 college savings plan, which is a tax-advantaged investment account, that is sponsored by states or educational institutions, and that is designed specifically for saving for college expenses. Here are some of the benefits and features, limitations and drawbacks, and tips and strategies, of 529 college savings plans:

Understanding 529 Plans

A 529 plan is a type of investment account, that allows you to save money for college expenses, and to enjoy tax benefits, such as:

  • Tax-deferred growth: This means that the money that you invest in a 529 plan, grows without being taxed, until you withdraw it, which allows your money to compound faster, and to accumulate more, over time.
  • Tax-free withdrawals: This means that the money that you withdraw from a 529 plan, is not taxed, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses, such as tuition, fees, books, supplies, room and board, and computers, at an eligible educational institution, such as a college, a university, a vocational school, or a trade school, that is accredited and recognized by the U.S. Department of Education.
  • State tax benefits: This means that some states may offer additional tax benefits, such as deductions, credits, or exemptions, for the money that you contribute to a 529 plan, depending on the state that you live in, and the state that sponsors the 529 plan, that you choose. You should check with your state’s tax authority, or a tax professional, to find out the specific tax benefits, that are available to you.

There are two types of 529 plans, that you can choose from, depending on your situation and goals:

  • 529 college savings plan: This is the more common and flexible type of 529 plan, that allows you to invest your money in a variety of investment options, such as mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, or target-date funds, that are offered by the 529 plan provider, and that are aligned with your risk tolerance and time horizon. You can choose from different investment portfolios, such as conservative, moderate, or aggressive, or age-based, or customized, and you can change your investment options, up to twice a year.
  • 529 prepaid tuition plan: This is the less common and less flexible type of 529 plan, that allows you to pay for future tuition costs, at today’s prices, at a specific educational institution, or a group of institutions, that participate in the 529 plan. You can buy a certain number of units or credits, that represent a percentage or a portion, of the tuition costs, at the selected institution or group of institutions, and you can use them in the future, when the beneficiary enrolls in the institution or group of institutions. However, you cannot use them for other education expenses, such as fees, books, supplies, room and board, or computers, or for other educational institutions, that do not participate in the 529 plan.

You can open a 529 plan account, for yourself or for a beneficiary, such as your child, grandchild, relative, friend, or anyone else, as long as you are a U.S. citizen or a resident alien, and you have a valid Social Security number or taxpayer identification number. You can also change the beneficiary of your 529 plan account, to another eligible person, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

Benefits and Features

Some of the benefits and features of 529 college savings plans are:

  • High contribution limits: 529 plans allow you to contribute a large amount of money, to your account, over time, depending on the state that sponsors the 529 plan, that you choose. The contribution limits can range from $200,000 to $500,000, per beneficiary, per state, which can cover most or all of the college expenses, for most or all of the college years, for most or all of the college students. However, you should be aware of the gift tax and the generation-skipping transfer tax implications, of making large contributions, to a 529 plan, in a single year, or over a lifetime, and consult with a tax professional, if needed.
  • Flexibility: 529 plans offer a lot of flexibility, in terms of choosing and changing the 529 plan provider, the investment options, the beneficiary, and the educational institution, that you want to use, for your college savings goals. You can choose any 529 plan provider, from any state, regardless of where you live, or where the beneficiary lives, or where the educational institution is located, as long as the 529 plan provider accepts out-of-state residents, and the educational institution is eligible. You can also change your 529 plan provider, up to once a year, without penalty, if you are not satisfied with their performance, or their fees, or their service. You can also choose from different investment options, that suit your risk tolerance and time horizon, and change your investment options, up to twice a year, without penalty, if you want to adjust your portfolio, or your strategy. You can also change the beneficiary of your 529 plan account, to another eligible person, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the IRS. You can also use your 529 plan account, for any eligible educational institution, in the U.S. or abroad, that is accredited and recognized by the U.S. Department of Education, without penalty, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses.
  • Protection from creditors: 529 plans offer some protection from creditors, in case of bankruptcy, or lawsuits, or other financial difficulties, that may affect your assets and income. Depending on the state that sponsors the 529 plan, that you choose, and the state that you live in, and the state that the beneficiary lives in, and the state that the creditor lives in, and the state that the court is located in, some or all of the money in your 529 plan account, may be exempt from the claims of creditors, or may have a certain degree of protection, from the claims of creditors. However, you should be aware of the rules and limitations, of the creditor protection, that apply to your 529 plan account, and consult with a legal professional, if needed.
  • Fees and associated costs: 529 plans may charge some fees and costs, that can reduce the returns and benefits, of your 529 plan account, such as:
    • Enrollment fee: This is a one-time fee, that some 529 plan providers may charge, when you open a 529 plan account, to cover the administrative and operational expenses, of setting up your account. The enrollment fee can range from $0 to $50, depending on the 529 plan provider, that you choose.
    • Annual maintenance fee: This is a recurring fee, that some 529 plan providers may charge, every year, to cover the ongoing administrative and operational expenses, of maintaining your account. The annual maintenance fee can range from $0 to $25, depending on the 529 plan provider, that you choose, and the balance and activity, of your account.
    • Program management fee: This is a recurring fee, that some 529 plan providers may charge, every year, to cover the expenses of managing and overseeing the investment options and portfolios, that are offered by the 529 plan. The program management fee can range from 0.00% to 0.50%, of the total assets, in your account, depending on the 529 plan provider, that you choose, and the investment options and portfolios, that you select.
    • Investment expense ratio: This is a recurring fee, that some 529 plan providers may charge, every year, to cover the expenses of investing and operating the underlying funds, that make up the investment options and portfolios, that are offered by the 529 plan. The investment expense ratio can range from 0.01% to 1.00%, of the total assets, in your account, depending on the 529 plan provider, that you choose, and the investment options and portfolios, that you select.

You should compare the fees and costs of different 529 plan providers, and choose the one that offers the lowest or no fees and costs, for the same or better service and performance, to maximize your returns and benefits, from your 529 plan account.

Contribution Limits

One of the limitations and drawbacks of 529 college savings plans, is the contribution limits, which are the maximum amounts of money, that you can contribute to your 529 plan account, over time, depending on the state that sponsors the 529 plan, that you choose. The contribution limits can range from $200,000 to $500,000, per beneficiary, per state, which can cover most or all of the college expenses, for most or all of the college years, for most or all of the college students. However, you should be aware of the following implications, of making large contributions, to a 529 plan, in a single year, or over a lifetime:

  • Gift tax: This is a federal tax, that applies to the transfer of money or property, from one person to another, as a gift, that exceeds the annual gift tax exclusion, or the lifetime gift tax exemption, which are the amounts of money or property, that you can give to another person, without paying any gift tax. The annual gift tax exclusion, for 2020 and 2021, is $15,000 per recipient, per year, which means that you can give up to $15,000, to each recipient, each year, without paying any gift tax. The lifetime gift tax exemption, for 2020 and 2021, is $11.58 million per donor, per lifetime, which means that you can give up to $11.58 million, to any number of recipients, over your lifetime, without paying any gift tax. However, if you exceed the annual gift tax exclusion, or the lifetime gift tax exemption, you may have to pay a gift tax, of up to 40%, of the excess amount, or report it to the IRS, and reduce your lifetime gift tax exemption, accordingly. Therefore, if you contribute more than $15,000, to a 529 plan, for a single beneficiary, in a single year, or more than $11.58 million, to a 529 plan, for any number of beneficiaries, over your lifetime, you may have to pay or report a gift tax, unless you use the special 529 plan rule, that allows you to treat a large contribution, as if it were made over five years, for gift tax purposes, which means that you can contribute up to $75,000, to a 529 plan, for a single beneficiary, in a single year, or up to $150,000, if you are married and file jointly, without paying or reporting a gift tax, as long as you do not make any additional contributions, to the same beneficiary, for the next four years. You should consult with a tax professional, if you plan to make large contributions, to a 529 plan, in a single year, or over a lifetime, to avoid or minimize the gift tax implications, of your contributions.
  • Generation-skipping transfer tax: This is a federal tax, that applies to the transfer of money or property, from one person to another, who is two or more generations younger, such as a grandparent to a grandchild, or a great-grandparent to a great-grandchild, that exceeds the generation-skipping transfer tax exemption, which is the amount of money or property, that you can give to a person, who is two or more generations younger, without paying any generation-skipping transfer tax. The generation-skipping transfer tax exemption, for 2020 and 2021, is $11.58 million per donor, per lifetime, which means that you can give up to $11.58 million, to any number of persons, who are two or more generations younger, over your lifetime, without paying any generation-skipping transfer tax. However, if you exceed the generation-skipping transfer tax exemption, you may have to pay a generation-skipping transfer tax, of up to 40%, of the excess amount, or report it to the IRS, and reduce your generation-skipping transfer tax exemption, accordingly. Therefore, if you contribute more than $11.58 million, to a 529 plan, for any number of beneficiaries, who are two or more generations younger, over your lifetime, you may have to pay or report a generation-skipping transfer tax, unless you use the special 529 plan rule, that allows you to treat a large contribution, as if it were made over five years, for generation-skipping transfer tax purposes, which means that you can contribute up to $75,000, to a 529 plan, for a single beneficiary, who is two or more generations younger, in a single year, or up to $150,000, if you are married and file jointly, without paying or reporting a generation-skipping transfer tax, as long as you do not make any additional contributions, to the same beneficiary, for the next four years. You should consult with a tax professional, if you plan to make large contributions, to a 529 plan, for any number of beneficiaries, who are two or more generations younger, over your lifetime, to avoid or minimize the generation-skipping transfer tax implications, of your contributions.
  • Excess contributions: This is a penalty, that the IRS may impose, if you contribute more than the contribution limit, to your 529 plan account, in a single year, or over a lifetime, which can result in double taxation, and reduced returns and benefits, of your 529 plan account. The excess contributions are treated as taxable income, to the beneficiary of the 529 plan account, and are subject to a 10% penalty, plus federal and state income taxes, on the earnings portion, of the excess contributions. Therefore, you should monitor your contributions, to your 529 plan account, and avoid exceeding the contribution limit, to avoid or minimize the excess contributions penalty, or withdraw the excess contributions, before the end of the tax year, to avoid or minimize the tax consequences, of the excess contributions.

Coverdell Education Savings Accounts (ESAs)

Another investment option for college savings, is the Coverdell education savings account, which is a tax-advantaged investment account, that is similar to 529 plans, but with some differences. Here are some of the features and benefits, limitations and drawbacks, and tips and strategies, of Coverdell ESAs:

Features of Coverdell ESAs

A Coverdell ESA is a type of investment account, that allows you to save money for education expenses, and to enjoy tax benefits, such as:

  • Tax-deferred growth: This means that the money that you invest in a Coverdell ESA, grows without being taxed, until you withdraw it, which allows your money to compound faster, and to accumulate more, over time.
  • Tax-free withdrawals: This means that the money that you withdraw from a Coverdell ESA, is not taxed, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses, not only for college, but also for elementary and secondary education, such as tuition, fees, books, supplies, equipment, uniforms, transportation, and academic tutoring, at an eligible educational institution, such as a public, private, or religious school, that provides elementary or secondary education, as determined by state law.

You can open a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, who is under the age of 18, or who has special needs, as long as you are a U.S. citizen or a resident alien, and you have a valid Social Security number or taxpayer identification number. You can also change the beneficiary of your Coverdell ESA account, to another eligible person, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the IRS.

Eligibility and Contribution Limits

One of the limitations and drawbacks of Coverdell ESAs, is the eligibility and contribution limits, which are the maximum amounts of money, that you can contribute to your Coverdell ESA account, depending on your income and the number of beneficiaries, that you have. The eligibility and contribution limits are as follows:

  • Income limit: This is the maximum amount of income, that you can have, to be eligible to contribute to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary. The income limit is based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI), which is your adjusted gross income (AGI), plus certain deductions, such as student loan interest, or foreign earned income exclusion. The income limit, for 2020 and 2021, is $110,000 for single filers, and $220,000 for married couples filing jointly, which means that you can contribute to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, if your MAGI is below these amounts. However, if your MAGI is between these amounts, and $95,000 for single filers, and $190,000 for married couples filing jointly, your contribution limit is reduced, by a phase-out formula, that reduces your contribution limit, by $50, for every $1,000, or fraction thereof, that your MAGI exceeds the lower limit. Therefore, if your MAGI is above these amounts, you cannot contribute to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, unless you use a special strategy, that involves contributing to a Coverdell ESA account, for yourself, and then changing the beneficiary, to the intended beneficiary, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the IRS.
  • Contribution limit: This is the maximum amount of money, that you can contribute to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, in a single year, regardless of the number of Coverdell ESA accounts, that you have, for the same beneficiary, or the number of contributors, that contribute to the same Coverdell ESA account, for the same beneficiary. The contribution limit, for 2020 and 2021, is $2,000 per beneficiary, per year, which means that you can contribute up to $2,000, to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, each year, as long as you meet the income limit, and the beneficiary meets the age limit, or has special needs. However, if you contribute more than $2,000, to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, in a single year, you may have to pay an excess contribution tax, of 6%, of the excess amount, per year, until you withdraw the excess amount, or correct the excess amount, by contributing less than $2,000, in a subsequent year, or by changing the beneficiary, to another eligible person, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the IRS.

You should consult with a tax professional, if you plan to contribute to a Coverdell ESA account, for a beneficiary, and you are not sure about your eligibility or contribution limits, or how to avoid or minimize the excess contribution tax, or how to use the special strategy, that involves contributing to a Coverdell ESA account, for yourself, and then changing the beneficiary, to the intended beneficiary, without penalty.

Qualified Education Expenses

One of the benefits and features of Coverdell ESAs, is the qualified education expenses, which are the expenses, that you can use the money in your Coverdell ESA account, for, without paying any taxes or penalties, as long as they are related to the education of the beneficiary, at an eligible educational institution. The qualified education expenses include:

  • Tuition and fees: These are the charges, that the educational institution imposes, for enrolling and attending the courses, programs, or degrees, that the beneficiary is pursuing, or intends to pursue, at the educational institution.
  • Books and supplies: These are the materials, that the beneficiary needs, to complete the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution, such as textbooks, notebooks, pens, pencils, calculators, or software.
  • Equipment: These are the items, that the beneficiary needs, to use the materials, that they need, to complete the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution, such as computers, printers, scanners, or internet access.
  • Uniforms: These are the clothing, that the beneficiary needs, to wear, to attend the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution, such as school uniforms, or sports uniforms.
  • Transportation: These are the costs, that the beneficiary incurs, to travel, to and from the educational institution, such as bus fares, subway fares, taxi fares, or parking fees.
  • Academic tutoring: These are the services, that the beneficiary receives, to improve their academic performance, or to prepare for standardized tests, such as SAT, ACT, or GRE, that are related to the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution, such as private tutors, or online tutors.

However, you should be aware of the following limitations and restrictions, of the qualified education expenses, for Coverdell ESAs:

  • Room and board: These are the costs, that the beneficiary incurs, to live and eat, while attending the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution, such as dorm fees, rent, utilities, groceries, or meal plans. Room and board are not qualified education expenses, for Coverdell ESAs, unless the beneficiary is enrolled at least half-time, at an eligible educational institution, that provides elementary or secondary education, as determined by state law, or at a college, a university, a vocational school, or a trade school, that is accredited and recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. In that case, the qualified room and board expenses, are limited to the lesser of the actual costs, or the allowance, that the educational institution includes, in its cost of attendance, for federal financial aid purposes.
  • Non-qualified education expenses: These are the expenses, that are not related to the education of the beneficiary, at an eligible educational institution, such as entertainment, travel, or personal expenses, that the beneficiary may incur, while attending the courses, programs, or degrees, that they are pursuing, or intend to pursue, at the educational institution. Non-qualified education expenses are not qualified education expenses, for Coverdell ESAs, and you cannot use the money in your Coverdell ESA account, for them, without paying taxes or penalties, on the earnings portion, of the withdrawal.

You should consult with a tax professional, if you are not sure about the qualified education expenses, for Coverdell ESAs, or how to avoid or minimize the taxes or penalties, of using the money in your Coverdell ESA account, for non-qualified education expenses.

  • Uniform Gifts to Minors Act (UGMA) and Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) accounts: These are custodial accounts, that allow you to transfer money or other assets, such as stocks, bonds, or real estate, to a minor, under the name and control of a custodian, such as a parent or a guardian, until the minor reaches the age of majority, which is usually 18 or 21, depending on the state. UGMA and UTMA accounts are not specifically designed for saving for college, but they can be used for any purpose, including education. However, UGMA and UTMA accounts have some drawbacks, such as limited tax benefits, loss of control, and negative impact on financial aid eligibility, that you should be aware of.

UGMA and UTMA Accounts

Another investment option for college savings, is the UGMA and UTMA account, which is a custodial account, that allows you to transfer money or other assets, to a minor, under the name and control of a custodian, until the minor reaches the age of majority. Here are some of the benefits and features, limitations and drawbacks, and tips and strategies, of UGMA and UTMA accounts:

Overview of UGMA and UTMA

A UGMA or UTMA account is a type of custodial account, that allows you to transfer money or other assets, to a minor, under the name and control of a custodian, until the minor reaches the age of majority, which is usually 18 or 21, depending on the state. The difference between UGMA and UTMA accounts, is the type of assets, that you can transfer, to the account. UGMA accounts allow you to transfer cash, securities, or insurance policies, to the account, while UTMA accounts allow you to transfer any type of asset, including real estate, art, or collectibles, to the account.

The main purpose of UGMA and UTMA accounts, is to provide a simple and convenient way, to transfer money or other assets, to a minor, without having to create a trust, or appoint a legal guardian, or go through a court process. However, UGMA and UTMA accounts are not specifically designed for saving for college, but they can be used for that purpose, as they offer some flexibility, in terms of choosing and changing the investment options, the beneficiary, and the educational institution, that you want to use, for your college savings goals.

You can open a UGMA or UTMA account, for a beneficiary, who is a minor, as long as you are a U.S. citizen or a resident alien, and you have a valid Social Security number or taxpayer identification number. You can also change the beneficiary of your UGMA or UTMA account, to another eligible person, without penalty, as long as they are a member of the same family, as defined by the IRS.

Custodial Accounts

One of the benefits and features of UGMA and UTMA accounts, is the custodial accounts, which are the accounts, that hold the money or other assets, that you transfer, to the beneficiary, under the name and control of a custodian, until the beneficiary reaches the age of majority. The custodial accounts offer some advantages, such as:

  • Ease of opening and managing: You can open a custodial account, for a beneficiary, at any financial institution, such as a bank, a brokerage firm, or a mutual fund company, that offers UGMA or UTMA accounts, by filling out a simple application form, and providing some basic information, such as your name, address, phone number, email, Social Security number or taxpayer identification number, and the name, address, phone number, email, and Social Security number or taxpayer identification number, of the beneficiary. You can also manage the custodial account, by making deposits, withdrawals, transfers, or changes, to the account, online, or by phone, or by mail, or in person, at the financial institution, that holds the account.
  • Variety of investment options: You can invest the money or other assets, in the custodial account, in a variety of investment options, such as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, certificates of deposit, or money market accounts, that are offered by the financial institution, that holds the account, and that are aligned with your risk tolerance and time horizon. You can choose from different investment portfolios, such as conservative, moderate, or aggressive, or customized, and you can change your investment options, at any time, without penalty, if you want to adjust your portfolio, or your strategy.
  • Control over the account: You have full control over the custodial account, as the custodian, until the beneficiary reaches the age of majority, which means that you can make all the decisions, regarding the account, such as how much to contribute, how to invest, when to withdraw, and who to transfer, the money or other assets, in the account, without the consent or involvement, of the beneficiary. You can also use the money or other assets, in the account, for any purpose, that benefits the beneficiary, such as education, health, or welfare, as long as you do not use them for your own benefit, or for expenses, that you are legally obligated to pay, as the parent or the guardian, of the beneficiary.

However, the custodial accounts also have some drawbacks, such as:

  • Irrevocability: You cannot revoke or undo, the transfer of money or other assets, to the custodial account, once you make it, which means that you cannot take back, or reclaim, or access, the money or other assets, in the account, for any reason, even if you change your mind, or have a financial emergency, or need the money or other assets, for yourself, or for another person. The money or other assets, in the account, belong to the beneficiary, and are subject to their rights and claims, as the owner, of the account.
  • Loss of control: You lose control over the custodial account, when the beneficiary reaches the age of majority, which means that you can no longer make any decisions, regarding the account, such as how to invest, when to withdraw, or who to transfer, the money or other assets, in the account, without the consent or involvement, of the beneficiary. The beneficiary can also use the money or other assets, in the account, for any purpose, that they want, such as education, travel, or entertainment, without your approval or guidance, or for purposes, that you may not agree with, or approve of, or support.
  • Tax considerations: The money or other assets, in the custodial account, are subject to federal and state income taxes, and gift taxes, and estate taxes, that may affect the returns and benefits, of the account, such as:
    • Income tax: This is a tax, that applies to the income, that the money or other assets, in the custodial account, generate, such as interest, dividends, or capital gains, that are earned, or realized, by the account, in a given year. The income tax is based on the tax rate, that applies to the beneficiary, as the owner, of the account, and the type and amount, of the income, that the account generates. The income tax rules, for custodial accounts, are as follows:
      • For beneficiaries, who are under the age of 19, or who are full-time students, under the age of 24, the first $1,100 of income, that the account generates, in a year, is tax-free, the next $1,100 of income, that the account generates, in a year, is taxed at the beneficiary’s tax rate, which is usually 10%, and any income, that exceeds $2,200, that the account generates, in a year, is taxed at the parent’s tax rate, which is usually higher, than the beneficiary’s tax rate. This is known as the kiddie tax, which is designed to prevent parents, from shifting income, to their children, to avoid or reduce taxes.
      • For beneficiaries, who are 19 or older, or who are not full-time students, under the age of 24, all the income, that the account generates, in a year, is taxed at the beneficiary’s tax rate, which is usually lower, than the parent’s tax rate, unless the beneficiary is subject to the alternative minimum tax, which is a separate tax system, that applies to certain taxpayers, with high income, or certain deductions, or preferences, that may reduce their regular tax liability, below a certain threshold.
    • Gift tax: This is a tax, that applies to the transfer of money or other assets, from one person to another, as a gift, that exceeds the annual gift tax exclusion, or the lifetime gift tax exemption, which are the amounts of money or property, that you can give to another person, without paying any gift tax. The annual gift tax exclusion, for 2020 and 2021, is $15,000 per recipient, per year, which means that you can give up to $15,000, to each recipient, each year, without paying any gift tax. The lifetime gift tax exemption, for 2020 and 2021, is $11.58 million per donor, per lifetime, which means that you can give up to $11.58 million, to any number of recipients, over your lifetime, without paying any gift tax. However, if you exceed the annual gift tax exclusion, or the lifetime gift tax exemption, you may have to pay a gift tax, of up to 40%, of the excess amount, or report it to the IRS, and reduce your lifetime gift tax exemption, accordingly. Therefore, if you contribute more than $15,000, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, for a beneficiary, in a single year, or more than $11.58 million, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, for any number of beneficiaries, over your lifetime, you may have to pay or report a gift tax, unless you use the special UGMA or UTMA rule, that allows you to treat a large contribution, as if it were made over five years, for gift tax purposes, which means that you can contribute up to $75,000, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, for a single beneficiary, in a single year, or up to $150,000, if you are married and file jointly, without paying or reporting a gift tax, as long as you do not make any additional contributions, to the same beneficiary, for the next four years. You should consult with a tax professional, if you plan to make large contributions, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, for a beneficiary, in a single year, or over a lifetime, to avoid or minimize the gift tax implications, of your contributions.
    • Estate tax: This is a tax, that applies to the transfer of money or property, from one person to another, at death, that exceeds the estate tax exemption, which is the amount of money or property, that you can leave to another person, without paying any estate tax. The estate tax exemption, for 2020 and 2021, is $11.58 million per person, per lifetime, which means that you can leave up to $11.58 million, to any number of persons, over your lifetime, without paying any estate tax. However, if you exceed the estate tax exemption, you may have to pay an estate tax, of up to 40%, of the excess amount, or report it to the IRS, and reduce your estate tax exemption, accordingly. Therefore, if you leave more than $11.58 million, to any number of persons, over your lifetime, you may have to pay or report an estate tax, unless you use the special UGMA or UTMA rule, that allows you to treat the transfer of money or other assets, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, as a completed gift, for estate tax purposes, which means that the money or other assets, in the account, are removed from your taxable estate, and are subject to the gift tax rules, instead of the estate tax rules. You should consult with a tax professional, if you plan to leave money or other assets, to a UGMA or a UTMA account, for a beneficiary, at death, to avoid or minimize the estate tax implications, of your transfer.

Roth IRA for Education Savings

Another investment option for college savings, is the Roth IRA, which is a type of individual retirement account, that allows you to invest your money in a variety of investment options, and to withdraw your contributions and earnings tax-free, after age 59 and a half, or for certain exceptions, such as education. Roth IRA is not specifically designed for saving for college, but it can be used for that purpose, as you can withdraw your contributions, at any time, without penalty, and your earnings, before age 59 and a half, without penalty, but with taxes, as long as you use them for qualified education expenses. Here are some of the advantages and considerations, limitations and drawbacks, and tips and strategies, of using a Roth IRA for education savings:

Using a Roth IRA for Education Expenses

A Roth IRA is a type of individual retirement account, that allows you to invest your money in a variety of investment options, such as stocks, bonds, or mutual funds, and to enjoy tax benefits, such as:

  • Tax-free growth: This means that the money that you invest in a Roth IRA, grows without being taxed, until you withdraw it, which allows your money to compound faster, and to accumulate more, over time.
  • Tax-free withdrawals: This means that the money that you withdraw from a Roth IRA, is not taxed, as long as you meet the following requirements:
    • You have had the Roth IRA, for at least five years, since the first year, that you made a contribution, to the account, or since the first year, that you converted a traditional IRA, to a Roth IRA, whichever is earlier. This is known as the five-year rule, which is designed to prevent people, from using a Roth IRA, as a short-term savings vehicle, to avoid taxes.
    • You are at least 59 and a half years old, or you qualify for one of the exceptions, that allow you to withdraw your money, from a Roth IRA, before age 59 and a half, without penalty, such as disability, death, first-time home purchase, or education. This is known as the qualified distribution rule, which is designed to encourage people, to use a Roth IRA, as a long-term savings vehicle, for retirement.

You can open a Roth IRA account, for yourself, as long as you are a U.S. citizen or a resident alien, and you have a valid Social Security number or taxpayer identification number, and you have earned income, such as wages, salaries, tips, commissions, or bonuses, from working for an employer, or self-employment income, from running your own business. You can also open a Roth IRA account, for your spouse, as long as you are married and file jointly, and you have earned income, that is at least equal to the amount, that you contribute, to both accounts.

Advantages and Considerations

Some of the advantages and considerations of using a Roth IRA for education savings are:

  • Flexibility: A Roth IRA offers a lot of flexibility, in terms of choosing and changing the investment options, the beneficiary, and the educational institution, that you want to use, for your college savings goals. You can choose any investment option, that suits your risk tolerance and time horizon, and that is offered by the financial institution, that holds your Roth IRA account, and you can change your investment options, at any time, without penalty, if you want to adjust your portfolio, or your strategy. You can also choose any beneficiary, that you want to use your Roth IRA account, for, such as yourself, your spouse, your child, your grandchild, or anyone else, and you can change the beneficiary, at any time, without penalty, as long as you withdraw the money, from your Roth IRA account, and give it to the beneficiary, or transfer it to another Roth IRA account, that belongs to the beneficiary. You can also use your Roth IRA account, for any eligible educational institution, in the U.S. or abroad, that is accredited and recognized by the U.S. Department of Education, without penalty, as long as you use it for qualified education expenses.
  • No impact on financial aid eligibility: A Roth IRA does not affect the financial aid eligibility, of the beneficiary, as it is not considered as an asset, or as income, in the calculation of the expected family contribution (EFC), which is the amount of money, that the federal government, or the state government, or the educational institution, expects the family, to pay, for the education expenses, of the beneficiary, based on the information, that the family provides, in the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA), which is the form, that the family fills out, to apply for financial aid, such as grants, scholarships, work-study, or loans. Therefore, having a Roth IRA account, does not reduce the amount of financial aid, that the beneficiary may receive, or increase the amount of financial aid, that the beneficiary may need, to pay for college expenses.
  • Opportunity cost: A Roth IRA has an opportunity cost, which is the value of the next best alternative, that is forgone, as a result of making a choice, between two or more mutually exclusive options, such as using a Roth IRA for education savings, or for retirement savings. The opportunity cost of using a Roth IRA for education savings, is the value of the retirement savings, that you could have accumulated, if you had used your Roth IRA for retirement savings, instead of for education savings. The opportunity cost of using a Roth IRA for education savings, depends on several factors, such as the amount and frequency of your contributions, the rate and duration of your growth, the amount and timing of your withdrawals, the tax rate and inflation rate, and the availability and suitability of other investment options, for education savings, or for retirement savings. You should consider the opportunity cost of using a Roth IRA for education savings, and compare it with the benefits and features of using a Roth IRA for education savings, and decide whether it is worth it, or not, for your situation and goals.

Withdrawal Rules

One of the limitations and drawbacks of using a Roth IRA for education savings, is the withdrawal rules, which are the rules, that govern how and when you can withdraw your money, from your Roth IRA account, for education expenses, without paying taxes or penalties, on the earnings portion, of the withdrawal. The withdrawal rules are as follows:

  • You can withdraw your contributions, at any time, without penalty, and without taxes, as long as you have had the Roth IRA, for at least five years, since the first year, that you made a contribution, to the account, or since the first year, that you converted a traditional IRA, to a Roth IRA, whichever is earlier. This is because your contributions, are made with after-tax money, which means that you have already paid taxes, on the money, that you contribute, to your Roth IRA account, and therefore, you do not have to pay taxes, again, when you withdraw your contributions, from your Roth IRA account.
  • You can withdraw your earnings, before age 59 and a half, without penalty, but with taxes, as long as you use them for qualified education expenses, such as tuition, fees, books, supplies, equipment, or computers, at an eligible educational institution, such as a college, a university, a vocational school, or a trade school, that is accredited and recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. This is because your earnings, are made with tax-free money, which means that you do not have to pay taxes, on the money, that you earn, in your Roth IRA account, as long as you meet the qualified distribution rule, or one of the exceptions, such as education. However, if you withdraw your earnings, before age 59 and a half, and you do not use them for qualified education expenses, or you do not qualify for one of the exceptions, you may have to pay a 10% penalty, plus federal and state income taxes, on the earnings portion, of the withdrawal.
  • You can withdraw your earnings, after age 59 and a half, without penalty, and without taxes, as long as you have had the Roth IRA, for at least five years, since the first year, that you made a contribution, to the account, or since the first year, that you converted a traditional IRA, to a Roth IRA, whichever is earlier. This is because your earnings, are made with tax-free money, which means that you do not have to pay taxes, on the money, that you earn, in your Roth IRA account, as long as you meet the qualified distribution rule, which is to be at least 59 and a half years old. However, if you withdraw your earnings, after age 59 and a half, and you have not had the Roth IRA, for at least five years, you may have to pay federal and state income taxes, on the earnings portion, of the withdrawal.

You should consult with a tax professional, if you are not sure about the withdrawal rules, for Roth IRAs, or how to avoid or minimize the taxes or penalties, of withdrawing your money, from your Roth IRA account, for education expenses.

High-Yield Savings Accounts

Another option for saving for college is to open a high-yield savings account. This is a type of bank account that offers a higher interest rate than a regular savings account, allowing you to grow your money faster. High-yield savings accounts are also FDIC-insured, which means your money is protected up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution.

Benefits of High-Yield Savings Accounts

  • They are easy to open and access online or through mobile apps
  • They have no or low minimum balance requirements and fees
  • They offer flexibility and liquidity, as you can withdraw or transfer your money at any time without penalties
  • They are safe and secure, as your money is backed by the federal government

Factors to Consider

  • They have variable interest rates, which means they can change over time depending on the market conditions
  • They have lower interest rates than other investment options, such as stocks or bonds, which means they may not keep up with inflation or the rising cost of college
  • They have tax implications, as you have to pay income tax on the interest you earn
  • They have opportunity costs, as you may miss out on higher returns from other investment options

High-yield savings accounts are best suited for short-term or emergency savings, or for saving a portion of your college fund that you plan to use within the next few years. They are not ideal for long-term or aggressive savings, as they may not offer enough growth potential or risk-reward ratio.

Investment Strategies for College Savings

Once you have chosen one or more investment options for your college savings, you need to follow some strategies to optimize your returns and minimize your risks. Here are some of the most important ones:

Diversification

Diversification means spreading your money across different types of investments, such as stocks, bonds, cash, and alternative assets. This way, you can reduce the impact of any single investment losing value, as well as take advantage of the different performance and growth potential of each asset class.

Diversification can also help you balance your risk and reward profile, as different investments have different levels of volatility and expected returns. For example, stocks tend to have higher returns but also higher risks than bonds, while cash and alternative assets can provide stability and hedge against inflation.

To diversify your portfolio, you should consider the following factors:

  • Your time horizon: how long you have until you need the money for college
  • Your risk tolerance: how comfortable you are with the possibility of losing money
  • Your investment goals: how much money you need to save for college
  • Your asset allocation: how you divide your money among different asset classes

As a general rule, the longer your time horizon, the higher your risk tolerance, and the higher your investment goals, the more you should invest in stocks and other growth-oriented assets. Conversely, the shorter your time horizon, the lower your risk tolerance, and the lower your investment goals, the more you should invest in bonds and other income-oriented assets.

You should also review and adjust your asset allocation periodically, as your circumstances and market conditions may change over time. For example, as you get closer to college, you may want to shift some of your money from stocks to bonds or cash, to preserve your capital and reduce your exposure to market fluctuations.

Assessing Risk Tolerance

Risk tolerance is the degree of uncertainty that you can handle in your investments. It is influenced by your personality, your financial situation, and your investment objectives. Risk tolerance can be classified into three categories:

  • Conservative: you prefer to avoid losses and prioritize safety and stability over growth. You are willing to accept lower returns in exchange for lower risks.
  • Moderate: you are willing to take some risks and seek a balance between growth and income. You can tolerate moderate fluctuations in your portfolio value and aim for moderate returns.
  • Aggressive: you are willing to take high risks and pursue high growth potential. You can withstand significant volatility in your portfolio value and expect high returns.

To assess your risk tolerance, you should ask yourself the following questions:

  • How much money can you afford to lose without jeopardizing your financial goals?
  • How do you react to market downturns and losses in your portfolio?
  • How long can you wait for your investments to recover from a loss?
  • How confident are you in your investment knowledge and skills?

Based on your answers, you can determine your risk tolerance level and choose the appropriate investments for your portfolio. You should also be honest and realistic about your risk tolerance, as investing beyond your comfort zone can lead to emotional stress and poor decision-making.

Regular Review and Adjustments

Investing for college is not a one-time event, but a continuous process that requires regular monitoring and evaluation. You should review your portfolio at least once a year, or more frequently if there are significant changes in your personal or financial situation, or in the market environment.

When you review your portfolio, you should check the following aspects:

  • Your performance: how your investments have performed over time, compared to your expectations and benchmarks
  • Your balance: how your portfolio is aligned with your asset allocation and risk tolerance
  • Your goals: how your portfolio is on track to meet your college savings target
  • Your costs: how much you are paying in fees, taxes, and commissions for your investments

Based on your review, you may need to make some adjustments to your portfolio, such as:

  • Rebalancing: restoring your portfolio to its original or desired asset allocation, by selling some of the over-performing assets and buying some of the under-performing ones
  • Reallocating: changing your asset allocation to reflect your changing time horizon, risk tolerance, or investment goals
  • Reinvesting: reinvesting your dividends, interest, or capital gains to compound your returns and grow your portfolio faster
  • Reducing: reducing your portfolio expenses by switching to lower-cost investments, such as index funds or ETFs, or by taking advantage of tax breaks, such as 529 plans or Roth IRAs

By reviewing and adjusting your portfolio regularly, you can ensure that your investments are working for you and not against you, and that you are on track to achieve your college savings goal.

Tips for Maximizing Returns on College Investments

Besides choosing the right investment options and strategies for your college savings, you can also follow some tips to maximize your returns and reach your goal faster. Here are some of the most effective ones:

Starting Early

The earlier you start saving for college, the more time you have to grow your money and benefit from the power of compounding. Compounding means earning interest on your interest, which can significantly increase your portfolio value over time.

For example, suppose you want to save $50,000 for college in 18 years, and you invest in a 529 plan that earns an average annual return of 7%. If you start saving $100 per month from the time your child is born, you will have $50,467 by the time they are 18. However, if you wait until your child is 10 years old, you will have to save $433 per month to reach the same goal. That’s more than four times the amount!

Therefore, starting early can help you save more with less effort, and reduce the need to take out loans or scholarships for college.

Consistent Contributions

Another tip to maximize your returns is to make consistent contributions to your college savings account, regardless of the market conditions. This way, you can take advantage of dollar-cost averaging, which means buying more shares when the prices are low and fewer shares when the prices are high. This can lower your average cost per share and increase your potential returns over time.

For example, suppose you invest $100 per month in a 529 plan that invests in stocks. In the first month, the stock price is $10, so you buy 10 shares. In the second month, the stock price drops to $5, so you buy 20 shares. In the third month, the stock price rises to $15, so you buy 6.67 shares. Your average cost per share is $8.33, and your total value is $555.56. However, if you had invested $300 in the first month and nothing in the next two months, your average cost per share would be $10, and your total value would be $450. You would have missed out on the opportunity to buy more shares at a lower price and earn more returns.

Therefore, consistent contributions can help you smooth out the market fluctuations and benefit from the long-term growth of your investments.

Okay, here is the final section of the article:

Conclusion

Saving for college can be a daunting task, but it can also be a rewarding one. By choosing the right investment options and strategies, you can make your money work for you and achieve your college savings goal.

In this article, we have explored some of the most popular and effective investment options for college savings, such as:

  • 529 college savings plans, which offer tax advantages, high contribution limits, and flexibility in choosing the beneficiary and the educational institution
  • Coverdell education savings accounts, which allow you to save for both K-12 and higher education expenses, with more investment choices and control
  • UGMA and UTMA accounts, which let you transfer assets to your child under a custodial arrangement, with lower taxes and fewer restrictions
  • Roth IRAs, which let you use your retirement savings for education expenses, without paying taxes or penalties on your contributions
  • High-yield savings accounts, which provide a safe and easy way to save for short-term or emergency needs, with higher interest rates than regular savings accounts

We have also discussed some of the key investment strategies for college savings, such as:

  • Diversification, which means spreading your money across different types of investments, to reduce risk and enhance returns
  • Assessing risk tolerance, which means determining how much uncertainty you can handle in your investments, based on your personality, financial situation, and investment objectives
  • Regular review and adjustments, which means monitoring and evaluating your portfolio performance, balance, goals, and costs, and making changes as needed

Finally, we have shared some tips to maximize your returns on college investments, such as:

  • Starting early, which means saving as soon as possible, to take advantage of the power of compounding and reduce the need for loans or scholarships
  • Consistent contributions, which means saving regularly, regardless of the market conditions, to benefit from dollar-cost averaging and long-term growth

We hope this article has helped you understand the basics of investing for college and inspired you to take action. Remember, the best time to start saving for college is now. The sooner you start, the easier it will be to reach your goal and make your child’s education dreams come true. 🎓

Leave a Comment

About The Author

Scroll to Top